Highest Score Equals the Sum of Other Scores
A table displaying shows where the highest panelist total score is equal to the sum of the two other panelists' total scores.
Scoring from Best Of and repeat shows are not included.
| Show Date | Scorekeeper | Panelist | Score | Rank |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1998-05-09 | Carl Kasell | Roxanne Roberts | 10 | First |
| Adam Felber | 5 | Second Tied | ||
| P.J. O'Rourke | 5 | Second Tied | ||
| 1998-09-26 | Carl Kasell | Adam Felber | 12 | First |
| Roxanne Roberts | 6 | Second Tied | ||
| Charlie Pierce | 6 | Second Tied | ||
| 1998-10-03 | Carl Kasell | Roxanne Roberts | 14 | First |
| Adam Felber | 10 | Second | ||
| Roy Blount, Jr. | 4 | Third | ||
| 1999-09-25 | Carl Kasell | Roxanne Roberts | 15 | First |
| Adam Felber | 9 | Second | ||
| Charlie Pierce | 6 | Third | ||
| 2001-03-10 | Carl Kasell | Roy Blount, Jr. | 14 | First |
| Charlie Pierce | 7 | Second Tied | ||
| Sue Ellicott | 7 | Second Tied | ||
| 2001-08-04 | Jean Cochran | Adam Felber | 16 | First |
| Roy Blount, Jr. | 9 | Second | ||
| Sue Ellicott | 7 | Third | ||
| 2003-01-11 | Carl Kasell | Adam Felber | 17 | First |
| Sue Ellicott | 9 | Second | ||
| P.J. O'Rourke | 8 | Third | ||
| 2006-11-18 | Carl Kasell | Roy Blount, Jr. | 18 | First |
| Paul Provenza | 13 | Second | ||
| Paula Poundstone | 5 | Third | ||
| 2012-07-14 | Carl Kasell | Roxanne Roberts | 18 | First |
| Peter Grosz | 12 | Second | ||
| Bobcat Goldthwait | 6 | Third | ||
| 2016-01-16 | Bill Kurtis | Roxanne Roberts | 17 | First |
| Mo Rocca | 12 | Second | ||
| Bobcat Goldthwait | 5 | Third | ||
| 2019-02-16 | Bill Kurtis | Luke Burbank | 13 | First |
| Alonzo Bodden | 9 | Second | ||
| Maeve Higgins | 4 | Third | ||
| 2021-07-31 | Bill Kurtis | Tom Bodett | 14 | First |
| Hari Kondabolu | 8 | Second | ||
| Maeve Higgins | 6 | Third | ||
| 2021-10-30 | Bill Kurtis | Amy Dickinson | 17 | First |
| Josh Gondelman | 12 | Second | ||
| Peter Grosz | 5 | Third | ||
| 2022-04-30 | Bill Kurtis | Amy Dickinson | 16 | First |
| Alzo Slade | 8 | Second Tied | ||
| Maeve Higgins | 8 | Second Tied | ||
| 2022-05-14 | Bill Kurtis | Faith Salie | 15 | First |
| Peter Grosz | 9 | Second | ||
| Laci Mosley | 6 | Third | ||
| 2022-05-21 | Bill Kurtis | Alonzo Bodden | 14 | First |
| Tom Papa | 9 | Second | ||
| Maeve Higgins | 5 | Third | ||
| 2023-05-27 | Bill Kurtis | Mo Rocca | 12 | First |
| Hari Kondabolu | 10 | Second | ||
| Maeve Higgins | 2 | Third | ||
| 2024-05-04 | Bill Kurtis | River Butcher | 16 | First |
| Joyelle Nicole Johnson | 8 | Second Tied | ||
| Josh Gondelman | 8 | Second Tied | ||
| Show Date | Scorekeeper | Panelist | Score | Rank |