Skip to main content

Highest Score Equals the Sum of Other Scores

A list of shows where the highest panelist total score is equal to the sum of the two other panelists' total scores.

Scoring from Best Of and repeat shows are not included.

Show Date Panelist Score Rank
1998-05-09 Roxanne Roberts 10 First
Adam Felber 5 Second Tied
P.J. O'Rourke 5 Second Tied
1998-09-26 Adam Felber 12 First
Roxanne Roberts 6 Second Tied
Charlie Pierce 6 Second Tied
1998-10-03 Roxanne Roberts 14 First
Adam Felber 10 Second
Roy Blount, Jr. 4 Third
1999-09-25 Roxanne Roberts 15 First
Adam Felber 9 Second
Charlie Pierce 6 Third
2001-03-10 Roy Blount, Jr. 14 First
Charlie Pierce 7 Second Tied
Sue Ellicott 7 Second Tied
2001-08-04 Adam Felber 16 First
Roy Blount, Jr. 9 Second
Sue Ellicott 7 Third
2003-01-11 Adam Felber 17 First
Sue Ellicott 9 Second
P.J. O'Rourke 8 Third
2006-11-18 Roy Blount, Jr. 18 First
Paul Provenza 13 Second
Paula Poundstone 5 Third
2012-07-14 Roxanne Roberts 18 First
Peter Grosz 12 Second
Bobcat Goldthwait 6 Third
2016-01-16 Roxanne Roberts 17 First
Mo Rocca 12 Second
Bobcat Goldthwait 5 Third
2019-02-16 Luke Burbank 13 First
Alonzo Bodden 9 Second
Maeve Higgins 4 Third
2021-07-31 Tom Bodett 14 First
Hari Kondabolu 8 Second
Maeve Higgins 6 Third
2021-10-30 Amy Dickinson 17 First
Josh Gondelman 12 Second
Peter Grosz 5 Third
2022-04-30 Amy Dickinson 16 First
Alzo Slade 8 Second Tied
Maeve Higgins 8 Second Tied
2022-05-14 Faith Salie 15 First
Peter Grosz 9 Second
Laci Mosley 6 Third
2022-05-21 Alonzo Bodden 14 First
Tom Papa 9 Second
Maeve Higgins 5 Third
2023-05-27 Mo Rocca 12 First
Hari Kondabolu 10 Second
Maeve Higgins 2 Third
2024-05-04 River Butcher 16 First
Joyelle Nicole Johnson 8 Second Tied
Josh Gondelman 8 Second Tied
Show Date Panelist Score Rank