Skip to main content

Single Appearance

A list of panelists who have only appeared on the show one time along with their total score and ranking.

Appearances on Best Of and repeat shows are not included.

Panelist Show Date Start Correct Score Rank
Alexandra Petri 2017-02-18 4 6 16 First
Alison Leiby 2020-05-23 3 4 11 Third
Aparna Nancherla 2015-04-25 2 5 12 Second
Atsuko Okatsuka 2021-11-20 2 2 6 Third
Cindy Chupack 2014-03-15 3 4 11 Second
Drew Carey 2008-04-26 3 5 13 Third
Fortune Feimster 2025-03-15 4 5 14 Second Tied
Gina Brillon 2021-07-17 4 4 12 Third
Hannibal Buress 2014-01-25 1 6 13 Second
Iliza Shlesinger 2015-09-26 2 2 6 Third
Jason Isbell 2024-04-27 2 4 10 Third
Jeff Garlin 2017-04-22 4 2 8 Third
Jeff Hiller 2025-06-21 4 6 16 First
Joanna Hausmann 2020-11-14 3 3 9 Third
John Hodgman 2017-11-18 3 5 13 First Tied
Ken Jennings 2013-06-01 4 6 16 First Tied
Liz Miele 2018-02-17 2 1 4 Third
Marina Franklin 2016-03-19 2 5 12 Third
Nell Benjamin 1998-10-24 2 2 6 Third
Nick Hancock 2011-12-24 6 5 16 First
Patton Oswalt 2017-08-05 2 5 12 Second
Paula Pell 2012-08-04 2 4 10 Third
Phoebe Robinson 2017-06-24 4 4 12 First Tied
Rachel Feinstein 2025-02-08 4 5 14 First
Rekha Shankar 2025-02-01 2 4 10 Second
Reza Aslan 2015-02-07 3 5 13 Third
River Butcher 2024-05-04 4 6 16 First
Robby Hoffman 2023-04-22 2 6 14 First
Rosie Perez 2014-05-31 2 4 10 Third
Scaachi Koul 2024-10-05 2 4 10 Third
Shannon O'Neill 2019-10-12 3 3 9 Third
Simon Amstell 2012-07-28 2 2 6 Third
Tig Notaro 2025-04-05 3 4 11 Second Tied
Yassir Lester 2021-01-30 2 5 12 Second
Zach Zimmerman 2025-06-07 2 5 12 Second
Panelist Show Date Start Correct Score Rank