Single Appearance

A list of panelists who have only appeared on the show one time along with their total score and ranking.

Appearances on Best Of and repeat shows are not included.

Panelist	Show Date	Start	Correct	Score	Rank
Alexandra Petri	2017-02-18	4	6	16	First
Alison Leiby	2020-05-23	3	4	11	Third
Aparna Nancherla	2015-04-25	2	5	12	Second
Atsuko Okatsuka	2021-11-20	2	2	6	Third
Cindy Chupack	2014-03-15	3	4	11	Second
Drew Carey	2008-04-26	3	5	13	Third
Fortune Feimster	2025-03-15	4	5	14	Second Tied
Gina Brillon	2021-07-17	4	4	12	Third
Hannibal Buress	2014-01-25	1	6	13	Second
Iliza Shlesinger	2015-09-26	2	2	6	Third
Jason Isbell	2024-04-27	2	4	10	Third
Jeff Garlin	2017-04-22	4	2	8	Third
Jeff Hiller	2025-06-21	4	6	16	First
Joanna Hausmann	2020-11-14	3	3	9	Third
John Hodgman	2017-11-18	3	5	13	First Tied
Ken Jennings	2013-06-01	4	6	16	First Tied
Liz Miele	2018-02-17	2	1	4	Third
Marina Franklin	2016-03-19	2	5	12	Third
Nell Benjamin	1998-10-24	2	2	6	Third
Nick Hancock	2011-12-24	6	5	16	First
Patton Oswalt	2017-08-05	2	5	12	Second
Paula Pell	2012-08-04	2	4	10	Third
Phoebe Robinson	2017-06-24	4	4	12	First Tied
Rachel Feinstein	2025-02-08	4	5	14	First
Rekha Shankar	2025-02-01	2	4	10	Second
Reza Aslan	2015-02-07	3	5	13	Third
River Butcher	2024-05-04	4	6	16	First
Robby Hoffman	2023-04-22	2	6	14	First
Rosie Perez	2014-05-31	2	4	10	Third
Scaachi Koul	2024-10-05	2	4	10	Third
Shannon O'Neill	2019-10-12	3	3	9	Third
Simon Amstell	2012-07-28	2	2	6	Third
Tig Notaro	2025-04-05	3	4	11	Second Tied
Yassir Lester	2021-01-30	2	5	12	Second
Zach Zimmerman	2025-06-07	2	5	12	Second
Panelist	Show Date	Start	Correct	Score	Rank