Skip to main content

Losing Streaks

A list of panelists with their longest string of appearances where they lost either by coming in tied for second or in third place, or losing outright by coming in third place.

Panelist All Losses Third Place Losses
Total # Shows Total # Shows
Aamer Haleem 7 7
  • 2005-03-19 (Third)
  • 2005-04-09 (Third)
  • 2005-06-25 (Third)
  • 2006-04-22 (Third)
  • 2006-06-24 (Third)
  • 2006-08-12 (Third)
  • 2006-11-11 (Second Tied)
6 6
  • 2005-03-19
  • 2005-04-09
  • 2005-06-25
  • 2006-04-22
  • 2006-06-24
  • 2006-08-12
Adam Burke 36 10
  • 2016-03-05 (Second)
  • 2016-04-30 (Second)
  • 2016-07-02 (Second)
  • 2016-07-30 (Second Tied)
  • 2016-09-17 (Third)
  • 2016-12-17 (Third)
  • 2017-03-18 (Third)
  • 2017-07-22 (Second)
  • 2017-08-05 (Third)
  • 2017-09-23 (Third)
13 3
  • 2016-09-17
  • 2016-12-17
  • 2017-03-18
Adam Felber 164 5
  • 1998-12-12 (Third)
  • 1998-12-19 (Second Tied)
  • 1998-12-26 (Third)
  • 1999-01-16 (Third)
  • 1999-02-06 (Second)
61 4
  • 2001-10-06
  • 2001-10-13
  • 2001-10-27
  • 2001-11-03
Aida Rodriguez 3 3
  • 2019-06-08 (Third)
  • 2019-08-03 (Second Tied)
  • 2019-12-07 (Third)
2 1
  • 2019-06-08
Alexandra Petri 0 0 - 0 0 -
Alison Leiby 1 1
  • 2020-05-23 (Third)
1 1
  • 2020-05-23
Alison Stewart 3 3
  • 2008-08-02 (Third)
  • 2008-08-30 (Second)
  • 2008-10-11 (Third)
2 1
  • 2008-08-02
Alonzo Bodden 75 17
  • 2016-04-02 (Third)
  • 2016-04-30 (Third)
  • 2016-08-13 (Third)
  • 2016-10-01 (Second)
  • 2016-11-05 (Second)
  • 2017-03-11 (Second)
  • 2017-04-08 (Second Tied)
  • 2017-05-13 (Third)
  • 2017-05-27 (Second)
  • 2017-06-17 (Third)
  • 2017-06-24 (Third)
  • 2017-08-12 (Third)
  • 2017-09-30 (Second)
  • 2017-11-04 (Third)
  • 2017-12-23 (Third)
  • 2018-01-20 (Second Tied)
  • 2018-03-10 (Second Tied)
31 3
  • 2010-11-13
  • 2011-02-05
  • 2011-06-04
Alzo Slade 11 8
  • 2022-01-29 (Third)
  • 2022-03-12 (Second Tied)
  • 2022-04-30 (Second Tied)
  • 2022-08-27 (Third)
  • 2022-10-08 (Third)
  • 2022-11-19 (Second Tied)
  • 2023-03-18 (Second)
  • 2023-08-26 (Second Tied)
5 2
  • 2022-08-27
  • 2022-10-08
Amy Dickinson 81 7
  • 2006-04-08 (Second)
  • 2006-06-17 (Third)
  • 2006-08-26 (Second Tied)
  • 2006-09-09 (Second Tied)
  • 2006-10-28 (Second)
  • 2006-12-02 (Second Tied)
  • 2007-01-13 (Second)
40 5
  • 2015-01-31
  • 2015-03-14
  • 2015-04-25
  • 2015-06-13
  • 2015-07-11
Andrea Michaels 1 1
  • 1999-01-23 (Second)
0 0 -
Angela Nissel 4 2
  • 2006-10-28 (Third)
  • 2006-12-09 (Second Tied)
1 1
  • 2006-10-28
Aparna Nancherla 1 1
  • 2015-04-25 (Second)
0 0 -
Ashley Ray 1 1
  • 2022-04-23 (Second)
0 0 -
Atsuko Okatsuka 1 1
  • 2021-11-20 (Third)
1 1
  • 2021-11-20
Bim Adewunmi 4 2
  • 2018-01-27 (Third)
  • 2018-06-09 (Second)
3 2
  • 2019-01-26
  • 2019-09-07
Bobcat Goldthwait 23 15
  • 2012-07-14 (Third)
  • 2012-12-22 (Third)
  • 2013-03-16 (Third)
  • 2013-05-18 (Third)
  • 2013-06-15 (Third)
  • 2013-08-03 (Third)
  • 2013-11-09 (Third)
  • 2014-03-22 (Third)
  • 2014-07-19 (Third)
  • 2014-11-08 (Third)
  • 2015-05-23 (Second Tied)
  • 2016-01-16 (Third)
  • 2016-03-05 (Third)
  • 2016-06-25 (Third)
  • 2016-08-06 (Third)
17 10
  • 2012-07-14
  • 2012-12-22
  • 2013-03-16
  • 2013-05-18
  • 2013-06-15
  • 2013-08-03
  • 2013-11-09
  • 2014-03-22
  • 2014-07-19
  • 2014-11-08
Brian Babylon 54 11
  • 2014-09-13 (Third)
  • 2014-10-25 (Second)
  • 2015-01-10 (Second)
  • 2015-02-28 (Second Tied)
  • 2015-03-28 (Third)
  • 2015-05-02 (Third)
  • 2015-08-01 (Third)
  • 2015-11-14 (Second Tied)
  • 2016-06-11 (Second)
  • 2016-07-16 (Third)
  • 2016-12-24 (Third)
31 4
  • 2013-10-12
  • 2013-11-23
  • 2014-01-25
  • 2014-02-15
Charla Lauriston 2 2
  • 2021-03-06 (Third)
  • 2021-06-12 (Third)
2 2
  • 2021-03-06
  • 2021-06-12
Charlie Pierce 179 15
  • 1998-07-11 (Second Tied)
  • 1998-07-18 (Third)
  • 1998-07-25 (Second)
  • 1998-08-08 (Second)
  • 1998-08-22 (Second)
  • 1998-08-29 (Second)
  • 1998-09-05 (Second)
  • 1998-09-19 (Third)
  • 1998-09-26 (Second Tied)
  • 1998-10-24 (Second)
  • 1998-10-31 (Third)
  • 1998-11-07 (Second)
  • 1998-11-14 (Second)
  • 1998-11-21 (Second Tied)
  • 1998-12-05 (Third)
71 4
  • 1999-04-17
  • 1999-05-01
  • 1999-05-15
  • 1999-06-05
Cindy Chupack 1 1
  • 2014-03-15 (Second)
0 0 -
Claudia Perry 2 2
  • 1999-03-27 (Second)
  • 1999-11-13 (Third)
1 1
  • 1999-11-13
Cristela Alonzo 5 3
  • 2021-09-18 (Second)
  • 2021-12-11 (Second)
  • 2022-01-22 (Second Tied)
1 1
  • 2023-02-18
Demi Adejuyigbe 2 2
  • 2020-03-07 (Third)
  • 2020-07-18 (Second)
1 1
  • 2020-03-07
Drew Carey 1 1
  • 2008-04-26 (Third)
1 1
  • 2008-04-26
Dulcé Sloan 14 6
  • 2020-07-25 (Third)
  • 2020-09-26 (Third)
  • 2020-11-07 (Third)
  • 2021-02-27 (Third)
  • 2021-06-19 (Second)
  • 2021-08-07 (Second)
6 4
  • 2020-07-25
  • 2020-09-26
  • 2020-11-07
  • 2021-02-27
Emmy Blotnick 11 4
  • 2023-01-14 (Second Tied)
  • 2023-06-10 (Third)
  • 2023-07-15 (Second Tied)
  • 2023-08-05 (Second Tied)
4 1
  • 2021-10-02
Eugene Cordero 7 7
  • 2020-10-24 (Second)
  • 2020-12-05 (Third)
  • 2023-01-21 (Third)
  • 2023-09-23 (Third)
  • 2023-12-09 (Third)
  • 2024-10-12 (Third)
  • 2025-03-22 (Second)
5 5
  • 2020-12-05
  • 2023-01-21
  • 2023-09-23
  • 2023-12-09
  • 2024-10-12
Evan Smith 2 2
  • 2001-12-22 (Second)
  • 2002-02-16 (Second)
0 0 -
Faith Salie 44 3
  • 2011-05-28 (Second)
  • 2011-06-18 (Second)
  • 2011-07-16 (Third)
13 2
  • 2010-09-11
  • 2010-11-20
Firoozeh Dumas 2 2
  • 2012-11-03 (Second)
  • 2013-03-09 (Second Tied)
0 0 -
Fortune Feimster 1 1
  • 2025-03-15 (Second Tied)
0 0 -
Gabe Liedman 2 1
  • 2015-03-21 (Second)
1 1
  • 2016-07-02
Gina Brillon 1 1
  • 2021-07-17 (Third)
1 1
  • 2021-07-17
Greg Proops 3 3
  • 2015-06-06 (Third)
  • 2016-01-09 (Second)
  • 2017-04-01 (Second Tied)
1 1
  • 2015-06-06
Hannibal Buress 1 1
  • 2014-01-25 (Second)
0 0 -
Hari Kondabolu 25 6
  • 2017-09-16 (Third)
  • 2017-12-02 (Third)
  • 2018-02-10 (Third)
  • 2018-05-26 (Second Tied)
  • 2018-06-16 (Second Tied)
  • 2018-10-20 (Third)
15 3
  • 2017-09-16
  • 2017-12-02
  • 2018-02-10
Helen Hong 41 7
  • 2016-02-06 (Second Tied)
  • 2016-05-07 (Third)
  • 2016-08-06 (Second)
  • 2016-10-08 (Third)
  • 2016-12-03 (Third)
  • 2017-01-28 (Second Tied)
  • 2017-03-11 (Third)
23 3
  • 2019-08-10
  • 2019-09-14
  • 2019-10-05
Iliza Shlesinger 1 1
  • 2015-09-26 (Third)
1 1
  • 2015-09-26
Janelle James 2 2
  • 2017-05-20 (Second)
  • 2018-05-12 (Third)
1 1
  • 2018-05-12
Jason Isbell 1 1
  • 2024-04-27 (Third)
1 1
  • 2024-04-27
Jeff Garlin 1 1
  • 2017-04-22 (Third)
1 1
  • 2017-04-22
Jeff Hiller 0 0 - 0 0 -
Jessi Klein 18 5
  • 2012-04-14 (Second Tied)
  • 2012-07-21 (Third)
  • 2012-08-25 (Third)
  • 2012-09-08 (Third)
  • 2012-12-15 (Third)
8 4
  • 2012-07-21
  • 2012-08-25
  • 2012-09-08
  • 2012-12-15
Joanna Hausmann 1 1
  • 2020-11-14 (Third)
1 1
  • 2020-11-14
Joel Kim Booster 5 2
  • 2019-11-23 (Third)
  • 2020-02-29 (Second Tied)
2 1
  • 2019-11-23
John Hodgman 0 0 - 0 0 -
Jordan Carlos 3 3
  • 2019-06-15 (Second)
  • 2019-07-13 (Second)
  • 2019-11-09 (Second)
0 0 -
Josh Gondelman 11 3
  • 2020-06-13 (Second Tied)
  • 2020-08-01 (Third)
  • 2020-09-05 (Second)
1 1
  • 2020-08-01
Joyelle Nicole Johnson 12 7
  • 2024-01-13 (Second)
  • 2024-02-03 (Third)
  • 2024-05-04 (Second Tied)
  • 2024-06-29 (Third)
  • 2024-08-31 (Second Tied)
  • 2024-10-05 (Second)
  • 2024-11-23 (Third)
6 1
  • 2024-02-03
Julia Sweeney 6 6
  • 2009-06-06 (Third)
  • 2009-07-11 (Second)
  • 2009-10-31 (Third)
  • 2009-12-05 (Third)
  • 2010-02-06 (Third)
  • 2010-07-03 (Third)
5 4
  • 2009-10-31
  • 2009-12-05
  • 2010-02-06
  • 2010-07-03
Karen Chee 13 8
  • 2021-12-04 (Second Tied)
  • 2022-01-29 (Second)
  • 2022-04-09 (Second)
  • 2022-09-24 (Third)
  • 2022-11-05 (Third)
  • 2023-06-17 (Second)
  • 2023-06-24 (Second)
  • 2023-09-30 (Third)
6 2
  • 2022-09-24
  • 2022-11-05
Karen Grigsby Bates 1 1
  • 2004-05-01 (Second)
0 0 -
Keegan-Michael Key 3 3
  • 2010-03-27 (Third)
  • 2010-05-01 (Third)
  • 2010-07-24 (Second Tied)
2 2
  • 2010-03-27
  • 2010-05-01
Ken Jennings 0 0 - 0 0 -
Ken Rudin 2 2
  • 2000-05-20 (Third)
  • 2000-06-10 (Third)
2 2
  • 2000-05-20
  • 2000-06-10
Kyrie O'Connor 44 3
  • 2004-11-20 (Third)
  • 2004-12-11 (Second)
  • 2005-01-15 (Second)
11 2
  • 2007-09-15
  • 2007-11-10
Laci Mosley 5 5
  • 2021-02-06 (Third)
  • 2021-05-01 (Third)
  • 2021-07-24 (Second Tied)
  • 2021-09-11 (Third)
  • 2022-05-14 (Third)
4 2
  • 2021-02-06
  • 2021-05-01
Liz Miele 1 1
  • 2018-02-17 (Third)
1 1
  • 2018-02-17
Luke Burbank 54 6
  • 2012-12-15 (Second)
  • 2013-02-16 (Third)
  • 2013-04-13 (Third)
  • 2013-06-15 (Second)
  • 2013-10-12 (Second)
  • 2014-01-18 (Second)
20 3
  • 2011-04-16
  • 2011-06-18
  • 2011-07-30
Maeve Higgins 33 22
  • 2020-12-12 (Third)
  • 2021-01-09 (Third)
  • 2021-04-10 (Third)
  • 2021-05-22 (Third)
  • 2021-07-31 (Third)
  • 2021-09-11 (Second)
  • 2021-12-11 (Third)
  • 2022-02-12 (Third)
  • 2022-04-02 (Third)
  • 2022-04-30 (Second Tied)
  • 2022-05-21 (Third)
  • 2022-06-18 (Third)
  • 2022-09-03 (Third)
  • 2023-03-04 (Third)
  • 2023-04-29 (Third)
  • 2023-05-27 (Third)
  • 2023-09-09 (Third)
  • 2023-11-04 (Third)
  • 2023-11-18 (Third)
  • 2024-01-13 (Third)
  • 2024-03-09 (Third)
  • 2024-04-13 (Third)
31 12
  • 2022-05-21
  • 2022-06-18
  • 2022-09-03
  • 2023-03-04
  • 2023-04-29
  • 2023-05-27
  • 2023-09-09
  • 2023-11-04
  • 2023-11-18
  • 2024-01-13
  • 2024-03-09
  • 2024-04-13
Margo Kaufman 14 7
  • 1998-02-21 (Third)
  • 1998-02-28 (Third)
  • 1998-03-07 (Second)
  • 1998-03-14 (Third)
  • 1998-03-28 (Second)
  • 1998-04-18 (Third)
  • 1998-04-25 (Second)
8 2
  • 1998-02-21
  • 1998-02-28
Marina Franklin 1 1
  • 2016-03-19 (Third)
1 1
  • 2016-03-19
Matt Rogers 3 2
  • 2023-05-06 (Third)
  • 2023-10-21 (Third)
3 2
  • 2023-05-06
  • 2023-10-21
Maz Jobrani 38 6
  • 2013-04-27 (Third)
  • 2013-07-13 (Third)
  • 2013-07-27 (Second)
  • 2013-10-05 (Third)
  • 2013-12-14 (Second)
  • 2014-02-15 (Second)
17 3
  • 2011-03-19
  • 2011-06-25
  • 2011-10-01
Meredith Scardino 2 2
  • 2024-05-11 (Third)
  • 2024-07-27 (Third)
2 2
  • 2024-05-11
  • 2024-07-27
Mike Birbiglia 2 1
  • 2014-03-08 (Third)
2 1
  • 2014-03-08
Mo Rocca 138 13
  • 2007-09-15 (Second)
  • 2007-10-06 (Second Tied)
  • 2007-11-03 (Third)
  • 2007-12-08 (Third)
  • 2008-01-19 (Third)
  • 2008-02-23 (Third)
  • 2008-03-15 (Third)
  • 2008-04-05 (Third)
  • 2008-05-10 (Third)
  • 2008-06-21 (Second)
  • 2008-07-26 (Third)
  • 2008-08-16 (Third)
  • 2008-09-06 (Third)
64 7
  • 2007-11-03
  • 2007-12-08
  • 2008-01-19
  • 2008-02-23
  • 2008-03-15
  • 2008-04-05
  • 2008-05-10
Moshe Kasher 1 1
  • 2015-03-28 (Second)
0 0 -
Negin Farsad 36 8
  • 2024-02-10 (Third)
  • 2024-04-13 (Second)
  • 2024-05-18 (Third)
  • 2024-06-22 (Third)
  • 2024-08-03 (Second)
  • 2024-09-14 (Third)
  • 2024-10-12 (Second)
  • 2024-11-09 (Second Tied)
17 3
  • 2020-10-10
  • 2020-11-21
  • 2021-01-16
Neko Case 2 2
  • 2013-09-07 (Third)
  • 2015-12-12 (Third)
2 2
  • 2013-09-07
  • 2015-12-12
Nell Benjamin 1 1
  • 1998-10-24 (Third)
1 1
  • 1998-10-24
Nick Hancock 0 0 - 0 0 -
Ophira Eisenberg 2 2
  • 2015-01-17 (Second)
  • 2015-02-28 (Second Tied)
0 0 -
P.J. O'Rourke 75 18
  • 1998-05-09 (Second Tied)
  • 2001-11-17 (Second Tied)
  • 2002-01-12 (Second)
  • 2002-02-09 (Second)
  • 2002-03-23 (Third)
  • 2002-04-13 (Second)
  • 2002-05-25 (Second)
  • 2002-06-08 (Third)
  • 2002-07-20 (Third)
  • 2002-08-24 (Second Tied)
  • 2002-10-26 (Second)
  • 2002-12-07 (Second Tied)
  • 2003-01-11 (Third)
  • 2003-02-15 (Third)
  • 2003-03-01 (Second)
  • 2003-05-17 (Second)
  • 2003-08-02 (Third)
  • 2003-08-16 (Third)
44 6
  • 2012-06-09
  • 2012-09-15
  • 2012-11-10
  • 2013-03-30
  • 2013-06-08
  • 2013-09-14
Patt Morrison 7 6
  • 2000-09-16 (Second Tied)
  • 2000-11-04 (Third)
  • 2000-12-23 (Third)
  • 2001-01-20 (Third)
  • 2001-03-17 (Second)
  • 2001-04-14 (Second Tied)
4 3
  • 2000-11-04
  • 2000-12-23
  • 2001-01-20
Patton Oswalt 1 1
  • 2017-08-05 (Second)
0 0 -
Paul Provenza 27 9
  • 2006-09-23 (Third)
  • 2006-11-18 (Second)
  • 2007-02-03 (Third)
  • 2007-03-17 (Second Tied)
  • 2007-05-12 (Third)
  • 2007-06-09 (Third)
  • 2007-07-14 (Third)
  • 2007-09-22 (Third)
  • 2007-10-20 (Second)
12 4
  • 2007-05-12
  • 2007-06-09
  • 2007-07-14
  • 2007-09-22
Paula Pell 1 1
  • 2012-08-04 (Third)
1 1
  • 2012-08-04
Paula Poundstone 199 15
  • 2001-02-17 (Third)
  • 2001-03-24 (Third)
  • 2001-05-12 (Third)
  • 2001-06-02 (Third)
  • 2002-05-04 (Third)
  • 2002-06-22 (Third)
  • 2002-07-27 (Third)
  • 2002-08-24 (Second Tied)
  • 2002-10-26 (Third)
  • 2002-11-23 (Third)
  • 2002-12-21 (Third)
  • 2003-01-25 (Third)
  • 2003-02-08 (Second)
  • 2003-03-29 (Third)
  • 2003-05-03 (Second)
103 7
  • 2001-02-17
  • 2001-03-24
  • 2001-05-12
  • 2001-06-02
  • 2002-05-04
  • 2002-06-22
  • 2002-07-27
Peter Grosz 55 10
  • 2019-04-06 (Third)
  • 2019-05-04 (Second)
  • 2019-06-22 (Third)
  • 2019-08-31 (Third)
  • 2019-09-14 (Second)
  • 2019-10-26 (Second)
  • 2019-12-14 (Third)
  • 2020-02-08 (Second)
  • 2020-03-14 (Second)
  • 2020-03-28 (Second)
21 3
  • 2011-12-10
  • 2012-01-28
  • 2012-02-18
Peter Sagal 6 2
  • 1998-02-14 (Second)
  • 1998-02-21 (Second)
3 1
  • 1998-01-10
Petey DeAbreu 2 2
  • 2019-05-04 (Third)
  • 2019-07-27 (Third)
2 2
  • 2019-05-04
  • 2019-07-27
Phoebe Robinson 0 0 - 0 0 -
Rachel Coster 3 3
  • 2025-01-11 (Third)
  • 2025-04-12 (Third)
  • 2025-06-21 (Third)
3 3
  • 2025-01-11
  • 2025-04-12
  • 2025-06-21
Rachel Feinstein 0 0 - 0 0 -
Rashawn Scott 2 2
  • 2018-03-24 (Third)
  • 2018-07-28 (Second Tied)
1 1
  • 2018-03-24
Rekha Shankar 1 1
  • 2025-02-01 (Second)
0 0 -
Reza Aslan 1 1
  • 2015-02-07 (Third)
1 1
  • 2015-02-07
Richard Roeper 7 4
  • 2005-06-11 (Second Tied)
  • 2005-07-30 (Third)
  • 2005-09-24 (Third)
  • 2006-07-15 (Second Tied)
4 2
  • 2004-08-07
  • 2004-09-04
River Butcher 0 0 - 0 0 -
Robby Hoffman 0 0 - 0 0 -
Rosie Perez 1 1
  • 2014-05-31 (Third)
1 1
  • 2014-05-31
Roxanne Roberts 187 10
  • 2003-11-08 (Third)
  • 2003-11-29 (Second)
  • 2003-12-13 (Third)
  • 2004-01-03 (Second Tied)
  • 2004-01-24 (Second)
  • 2004-02-14 (Second)
  • 2004-02-21 (Third)
  • 2004-03-06 (Second)
  • 2004-03-20 (Second Tied)
  • 2004-04-17 (Second)
63 3
  • 1998-06-13
  • 1998-06-27
  • 1998-07-04
Roy Blount, Jr. 191 9
  • 2009-06-20 (Third)
  • 2009-07-18 (Second Tied)
  • 2009-08-15 (Second)
  • 2009-09-19 (Second)
  • 2009-10-17 (Second)
  • 2009-11-21 (Third)
  • 2009-12-12 (Third)
  • 2010-02-27 (Second)
  • 2010-03-13 (Third)
83 4
  • 2010-05-15
  • 2010-07-31
  • 2010-08-14
  • 2010-10-02
Scaachi Koul 1 1
  • 2024-10-05 (Third)
1 1
  • 2024-10-05
Shane O'Neill 8 6
  • 2022-12-24 (Second Tied)
  • 2023-03-11 (Third)
  • 2023-04-15 (Third)
  • 2023-08-05 (Second Tied)
  • 2024-01-27 (Third)
  • 2024-06-08 (Third)
4 2
  • 2023-03-11
  • 2023-04-15
Shannon O'Neill 1 1
  • 2019-10-12 (Third)
1 1
  • 2019-10-12
Shantira Jackson 11 11
  • 2023-08-26 (Second Tied)
  • 2023-10-07 (Second)
  • 2023-12-23 (Third)
  • 2024-04-27 (Second)
  • 2024-05-25 (Second Tied)
  • 2024-07-20 (Second)
  • 2024-09-28 (Third)
  • 2025-02-08 (Third)
  • 2025-03-08 (Third)
  • 2025-05-10 (Third)
  • 2025-08-02 (Third)
6 5
  • 2024-09-28
  • 2025-02-08
  • 2025-03-08
  • 2025-05-10
  • 2025-08-02
Shelby Fero 3 3
  • 2014-06-28 (Third)
  • 2014-09-27 (Third)
  • 2014-12-13 (Third)
3 3
  • 2014-06-28
  • 2014-09-27
  • 2014-12-13
Simon Amstell 1 1
  • 2012-07-28 (Third)
1 1
  • 2012-07-28
Skyler Higley 3 2
  • 2022-09-03 (Second)
  • 2022-12-03 (Third)
2 1
  • 2022-12-03
Sue Ellicott 101 23
  • 2004-08-07 (Second)
  • 2004-08-28 (Third)
  • 2004-09-18 (Third)
  • 2004-09-25 (Second)
  • 2004-10-02 (Third)
  • 2004-11-06 (Third)
  • 2004-11-20 (Second)
  • 2004-12-18 (Third)
  • 2005-02-05 (Third)
  • 2005-02-19 (Second)
  • 2005-03-05 (Second)
  • 2005-04-02 (Second Tied)
  • 2005-05-14 (Third)
  • 2005-08-20 (Third)
  • 2005-10-01 (Second)
  • 2005-10-22 (Third)
  • 2005-11-12 (Second)
  • 2005-12-03 (Second Tied)
  • 2006-01-14 (Third)
  • 2006-02-04 (Third)
  • 2006-03-18 (Second)
  • 2006-04-29 (Second Tied)
  • 2006-06-03 (Second)
52 6
  • 2003-06-21
  • 2003-07-12
  • 2003-08-09
  • 2003-08-23
  • 2003-09-13
  • 2003-09-27
Tara Clancy 3 3
  • 2018-05-19 (Second)
  • 2018-09-22 (Second)
  • 2018-11-17 (Third)
1 1
  • 2018-11-17
Tig Notaro 1 1
  • 2025-04-05 (Second Tied)
0 0 -
Tom Bodett 111 7
  • 2008-01-12 (Third)
  • 2008-02-16 (Second)
  • 2008-03-15 (Second)
  • 2008-04-05 (Second)
  • 2008-04-12 (Second)
  • 2008-04-19 (Third)
  • 2008-05-24 (Third)
49 3
  • 2013-09-28
  • 2013-11-02
  • 2013-12-21
Tom Papa 14 6
  • 2018-06-30 (Third)
  • 2018-12-01 (Third)
  • 2019-05-25 (Third)
  • 2020-02-15 (Second)
  • 2020-05-16 (Second Tied)
  • 2020-06-20 (Third)
6 3
  • 2018-06-30
  • 2018-12-01
  • 2019-05-25
Tracy Clayton 2 2
  • 2017-06-10 (Third)
  • 2020-08-08 (Third)
2 2
  • 2017-06-10
  • 2020-08-08
Yassir Lester 1 1
  • 2021-01-30 (Second)
0 0 -
Zach Zimmerman 1 1
  • 2025-06-07 (Second)
0 0 -
Zainab Johnson 5 5
  • 2022-12-17 (Third)
  • 2023-02-04 (Third)
  • 2023-04-01 (Third)
  • 2023-07-29 (Third)
  • 2023-10-28 (Third)
5 5
  • 2022-12-17
  • 2023-02-04
  • 2023-04-01
  • 2023-07-29
  • 2023-10-28
Panelist Total # Shows Total # Shows
All Loses Third Place Losses